Mac vs PC. Microsoft vs Google. Intel vs AMD. There's no shortage of
monumental rivalries in the tech industry. But the royal rumble between
ATI and Nvidia for dominance of 3D graphics is one of the roughest of
the lot.
The contest is really AMD vs Nvidia. After all, AMD snapped up Canadian graphics outfit ATI back in 2006.
More
importantly, however you slice it the histories of ATI and Nvidia have
been very closely intertwined. Both started out as specialists in PC
graphics and have since branched out into non-PC platforms such as games
consoles, mobile devices and set-top boxes.
More recently, ATI's
acquisition by AMD seems to have set it on a very different path for the
future from Nvidia. But let's start by reminiscing on a few of our
favourite ATI vs Nvidia fisticuffs from yesteryear before taking a look
at their current offerings.
AMD vs Nvidia: RIVA and Rage
The
early days of graphics on the PC saw 3D cards like Nvidia's RIVA 128
and TNT2 take on ATI's Rage and Rage 128. But it was Nvidia who presaged
the modern GPU or Graphics Processing Unit with the mighty GeForce 256
in 1999. It was the first graphics chip with hardware transform and
lighting capabilities. And it was fast. Damned fast.
ATI responded
in 2000 with the Radeon graphics card. Ever since, successive
generations of GeForce and Radeon GPUs have been leapfrogging each other
in the race for graphics supremacy. Nvidia had the early advantage with
the GeForce, GeForce 2, GeForce 3 and GeForce 4 series arguably having
the edge over ATI's Radeon, Radeon 7500 and Radeon 8500.
But
in 2002 ATI turned the tables with the awesome Radeon 9700 Pro. The
first GPU with fully programmable shaders, the 9700 Pro was massively
more powerful than any graphics chip before. It took until early 2003
for Nvidia to respond with the ill-fated GeForce 5800 Ultra, a GPU that
never lived up to expectations.
Nvidia was back on form a year
later with the GeForce 6800 series. A tit for tat ensued with neither
ATI nor Nvidia achieving a clear advantage. It was during this period
that Nvidia introduced its revolutionary multi-GPU SLI technology and
ATI responded with the copycat Crossfire platform. There really was
nothing to separate them.
AMD vs Nvidia: Radeon rethink

At least, there wasn't until ATI released the underperforming
Radeon HD 2900 XT.
Like Nvidia's calamitous GeForce FX series, the 2900 arrived late, ran
hot, underperformed and couldn't match its opposition, the
GeForce 8800 Ultra.
But
unlike the GeForce FX, it lead to a fundamental strategic rethink. AMD
decided that in future ATI would no longer chase ultimate performance
with its top GPU. Instead it would aim for maximum bang for buck and
introduce dual-GPU boards to cater for enthusiasts demanding ultra-high
performance.
The culmination of this rethink was the
Radeon HD 4870. Launched in mid 2008, it was half the price of Nvidia's competing
GeForce GTX 280 but delivered at least 80 per cent of the performance. It was a winning combination.
AMD vs Nvidia: The DX11 era
Of
course, graphics technology waits for no man and much has changed since
the Radeon HD 4000 series and GeForce GTX 200 hit the market in 2008.
Late last year AMD unleashed the Radeon HD 5000 series, the world's
first family of graphics chips with support for the latest DirectX 11
multimedia API from Microsoft, as seen in Windows 7 but also available
as an update for Windows Vista.
It took a little longer for
Nvidia to respond in kind with the GeForce GTX 400 family. It eventually
turned up earlier this year and since then its been these two pixel
pumping graphics architectures fighting it out for top DX11 honours.
Topping the current single-GPU tables, therefore, are the
ATI Radeon HD 5870 and
Nvidia Geforce GTX 480. Thanks to AMD's greater emphasis on value, the GTX 480 weighs in around £100 more expensive at £430 or so.
For
the money Nvidia gives you an extra billion transistors for a faintly
ridiculous total of three billion. You also get a little more memory as
standard, 1.5GB to the 5870's 1GB. However, it's worth noting that
2GB variants of the 5870 are now available for less than the 1.5GB GTX 480.
Anyway,
what you don't get from the 480 is a huge performance advantage. Yes
it's a little quicker than the 5870. But not nearly as much as it needs
to be given the extra cost and complexity.
AMD vs Nvidia: Cut-down cards

It's
a similar story further at the next rung down the graphics ladder. Both
AMD and Nvidia offer slightly cut down versions of their top GPUs. The
Radeon HD 5850 is yours for £225 and retains 1,440 of the 5870's 1,600 stream shaders. Meanwhile, Nvidia's
GeForce GTX 470 weighs in around £295 and packs 448 of Nvidia's mighty CUDA cores. The GTX 480, for the record, has 480 cores.
Once
again, the 470 is a little quicker than its AMD equivalent, but it's
also much more expensive. From there, things get a little more
complicated. AMD does a silly-money dual-GPU Radeon HD 5000 board, the
5970.
In most tests of pixel pumping prowess, it's the quickest thing out
there (NVIDIA has yet to wheel out a dual-GPU take on the GTX 400
series). But just occasionally its dual-GPU architecture and
split-memory set up gets the better of it.
Move into mid-range
territory and direct comparisons between ATI and Nvidia are currently a
bit tricky. That's because Nvidia has yet to release more affordable
chips based on Fermi, the new DX11 architecture that underpins the GTX
480 and 470 GPUs.
Consequently, the
Radeon HD 5770 (£125),
Radeon HD 5670 (£85) and
Radeon HD 5570 (£72) are lording it without any DX11 competition.
Instead, Nvidia makes do with older chipsets based on DX10 tech, such as the
GeForce GTS 250 (£125) and
GeForce GT 240 (£72).
Advantage Nvidia?
That
said, Nvidia has recently released an even more cut-down version of the
Fermi chip in the new GeForce GTX 465, on sale now from around £230.
But what it really needs is some pukka mid-range DX11 chips to take the
fight to AMD. And it needs them soon. AMD has already released its
family of second-generation DirectX 11 GPUs.
Read ourAMD Radeon HD 6870 review
In
the meantime, it's not all bad news for Nvidia. Arguably, it has an
edge in at least one important DX11 feature, the hardware tessellator.
Designed to spew out huge numbers of polygons and therefore give games
more geometric detail and realism than ever before, the tessellator
could prove to be the killer feature in DX11. Early tests suggest
Nvidia's chips have more tessellation power than ATI's.
Nvidia is
also way ahead of ATI when it comes to stereoscopic 3D. Nvidia's 3D
Vision technology is the best way to get 3D on your PC today. It works
with a
large number of games
and is also compatible with certain formats of 3D movies including
Blu-ray 3D. But like most other 3D display technologies, wearing a pair
of geeky goggles is the price of participation.
source of article